Mechanic: Closed Drafting
See All
Overview
Closed drafting is a board game mechanic that involves players selecting cards or other game elements from a limited pool, usually face-down, in a predetermined order. This mechanic adds an element of strategy and decision-making to the game, as players must carefully consider their options and anticipate the choices of their opponents. Closed drafting can be found in various board games, including Agricola (Revised Edition), Blood Rage, and Agricola.
Gameplay/Functionality
In closed drafting, players typically have a set number of choices available to them, often represented by cards or tiles. These choices are usually placed face-down, making it impossible for players to know the exact contents of the pool. Players take turns selecting one item from the pool until all choices have been made.
The order in which players make their selections can be predetermined or determined by a specific game mechanism, such as turn order or player position. This adds an additional layer of strategy, as players must consider not only the available options but also the potential choices of their opponents.
Closed drafting can have different effects on gameplay depending on the specific game. It can create tension and competition as players vie for the most desirable options. It also introduces an element of uncertainty, as players must make decisions based on limited information. This mechanic encourages players to think strategically, adapt to changing circumstances, and anticipate the choices of their opponents.
Examples from Popular Games
Agricola (Revised Edition) is a prime example of a game that utilizes closed drafting. In this game, players take turns selecting cards from a face-down pool, which represent various improvements and occupations. These cards provide players with unique abilities and resources, allowing them to develop their farms and score points. The closed drafting mechanic in Agricola adds depth and replayability to the game, as players must adapt their strategies based on the available cards and the choices made by their opponents.
Blood Rage is another game that incorporates closed drafting. In this Viking-themed game, players draft cards representing different units, upgrades, and quests. These cards enhance players' abilities and contribute to their overall strategy in battles and quests. The closed drafting mechanic in Blood Rage creates intense competition among players, as they must carefully select cards that synergize with their chosen strategies while denying valuable options to their opponents.
Agricola, the original version, also features closed drafting. Players select occupation and improvement cards to enhance their farming capabilities. The closed drafting mechanic in Agricola adds an element of surprise and strategic planning, as players must carefully consider the available cards and anticipate the choices of their opponents to optimize their farm's efficiency.
Why People Enjoy It
Closed drafting is a popular mechanic among board game enthusiasts for several reasons. Firstly, it adds an element of strategy and decision-making, as players must carefully evaluate their options and anticipate the choices of their opponents. This creates a dynamic and engaging gameplay experience.
Secondly, closed drafting introduces an element of uncertainty and surprise. Players must make decisions based on limited information, which adds tension and excitement to the game. The unpredictability of the available options keeps players on their toes and encourages them to think creatively and adapt their strategies.
Lastly, closed drafting promotes interaction and competition among players. As players vie for the most desirable options, they must consider not only their own choices but also the potential choices of their opponents. This creates a sense of rivalry and strategic maneuvering, making the game more engaging and enjoyable.
Overall, closed drafting is a mechanic that enhances gameplay by adding strategic decision-making, uncertainty, and competition. Its inclusion in games like Agricola (Revised Edition), Blood Rage, and Agricola contributes to their popularity and replayability among board game enthusiasts.